Inspection scope
Cooling systems are not required, and having none is not a deficiency. Still, the home inspector should consider telling the client that the house has none. Doing so is especially important in markets where cooling systems are common.
A cooling system may be one or more central systems that cool the whole house. It may instead be one or more appliances that each cool a single room. Permanently installed systems are in scope, including through-wall units. Window units and other portable units are out of scope, because they are considered personal property. Reporting a window unit that was not inspected is best practice. Some home inspectors elect to inspect window units.
The condenser, refrigerant tubes, evaporator coil, and air handler are in scope. So are standard filters, auxiliary drain pans, and condensate disposal tubes. Electrostatic filters and other special filters are out of scope, and so are ultraviolet lights and other air purifiers (sanitation devices).
Cooling system terms
Broadly, air conditioning covers cooling, heating, dehumidification, humidification, air filtration, and ventilation. In residential construction it usually means only cooling, dehumidification, air filtration, and ventilation.
A central air conditioning system has a condenser unit, an evaporator coil, and an air handler or furnace. It moves heat from inside the house to the outside. In a split system, the evaporator coil and fan are inside and the condenser unit is outside. Split systems are the most common type. In a package system, the evaporator coil and fan share one cabinet. The unit is usually outside on the ground or the roof, but may be inside. An inside unit is usually in multi-family housing.
The air handler is the indoor unit of a heat pump, with a fan (blower), an evaporator coil, and controls. The term sometimes also describes a forced air furnace that burns fuel.
The condenser unit is the outdoor unit of a split system. It holds a fan, controls, the condenser coils, and the compressor. The condenser coils are the tubes around the perimeter of the cabinet. The compressor compresses refrigerant gas into superheated gas and supplies the energy that moves refrigerant through the system.
A heat pump both heats and cools. In heating mode it moves heat from outdoors into the house. In cooling mode it removes heat from the house.
Capacity is stated in tons or in British thermal units (Btu). One Btu is the heat that warms 1 pound of water 1 degree F. One ton of refrigeration equals 12,000 Btu per hour, so a 3-ton system has a capacity of 36,000 Btu.
SEER (seasonal energy efficiency ratio) measures cooling efficiency, for an air conditioner or for a heat pump that is cooling. It is the output over a cooling season divided by the electric energy used. Currently, 14 is the minimum allowed SEER in most of the United States. Around 20 is the highest available, and older systems may rate 10 or less. These figures may differ in some states. HSPF (heat seasonal performance factor) rates heat pump efficiency for heating the same way. HSPF ratings run from about 7 to 10.
The refrigerant (coolant) flows through the liquid and suction tubes. Production of Freon (R-22), the refrigerant in older systems, was phased out for environmental reasons. The manual identifies R-410A as the current refrigerant. Newer systems use other refrigerants. Exam answers follow the manual.
The line set is the pair of tubes linking the evaporator coil and the condenser. The suction line is the larger, insulated copper tube. The liquid line is the smaller copper tube and is usually uninsulated. Schrader valves at the condenser unit are where technicians connect a gauge set to measure refrigerant line pressures. They are similar to automobile tire valves.
Equipment classifications
By function. Some equipment only cools. A warm-air furnace (electric, gas, or oil) usually supplies the heat. Heat pumps both heat and cool.
By area served. Central equipment serves the entire house or large parts of it. Room equipment serves one room or a few. It includes the newer mini-split, window units, and through-wall units.
By configuration. Central equipment may be a split system or a package system.
By duct type. Large low velocity ducts serve most central equipment. Systems with smaller high velocity ducts are uncommon. Mini-splits have no ducts.
By region. The evaporative cooler (swamp cooler) is found in the arid west, mostly in older houses. The radiant cooling system is another arid west system. It circulates cool water through pipes in the ceiling or floor, and heat moves into the water by conduction and radiation. It handles only the sensible load, so it is not recommended where humidity is high. Home inspectors should disclaim radiant cooling, which is uncommon, and recommend that a qualified contractor evaluate it under the manufacturer's instructions.
By house size. Absorption heat pumps and absorption coolers are currently sold only for larger houses. In place of a compressor they use an absorber, and their refrigerant is ammonia. Fuel is propane, natural gas, or renewable energy. Most absorption systems serve commercial and industrial uses, and they are uncommon in houses. An absorption cooler may serve as a refrigerator where electricity is hard or costly to get, such as an off-grid house. Because they are uncommon, home inspectors should disclaim them.
Uncommon combinations. A dual fuel system may pair a gas or oil furnace with an electric heat pump. A home inspector should be able to inspect one. A hybrid heat pump system combines technologies, such as air-source and ground-source. Hybrids are very uncommon in houses.
Air, ground, and water source heat pumps
Heat pumps are also classified by where they exchange heat with the environment. Air-source heat pumps are the vast majority. Their condenser unit exchanges heat with outside air.
A ground-source heat pump uses buried or drilled tubes to exchange heat with the ground. It is commonly, and incorrectly, called geothermal. A water-source heat pump exchanges heat with water. It uses tubes submerged in a well or a lake, or a mechanical means such as a cooling tower that lets the water exchange heat with air. In heating mode either type draws heat out of the ground or water and moves it into the house. In cooling mode it moves heat from the house into the ground or water.
Each ground-source or water-source system is either closed-loop or open-loop. In a closed-loop system the exchange medium, usually a water and antifreeze mixture or water, circulates in sealed tubes that have no opening to the environment. An open-loop system takes water from an aquifer (ground water) or a lake and returns it to its source. A ground-source heat pump is closed-loop. A water-source heat pump may be open-loop or closed-loop.
Air-source heat pumps are less efficient than ground-source and water-source heat pumps. Below the surface by a few feet, ground and large bodies of water hold a relatively constant temperature. Air temperature can vary significantly. At high air temperatures an air-source heat pump struggles to shed heat, and at low temperatures it struggles to absorb heat. A heat pump under these conditions is both inefficient and ineffective. Much below 30 degrees F, a heat pump can become so ineffective that climates regularly colder than 30 degrees F require supplemental electric heat strips.
Reports put ground-source and water-source systems at up to 50 percent more energy efficient than air-source systems. They are uncommon because of high installation cost and the five to ten years needed to recover the added cost through energy savings. Buyers who want a smaller carbon footprint favor them, but they are a niche product. A ground-source system can need a large amount of land for its tubes, especially a horizontal system, with tubes in trenches. A vertical system, with tubes drilled into the ground, needs less land.
All three types operate on the same principles. They differ in installation and in the connection to the ground or water, and many of those details are concealed. Home inspectors should run every heat pump when possible and report leaks and other obvious visible defects. Beyond that, inspecting ground-source and water-source systems is out of scope. Home inspectors should recommend that a qualified HVAC contractor evaluate them.
How air conditioners work
Home inspectors are not expected to know air conditioning repair. A home inspector should know the basics of how the systems work, in order to interpret inspection results.
Basic theory
These simplified statements assume no outside mechanical force affects the system.
- Heat energy flows from a hotter place to a colder place.
- Water vapor diffuses from air with more water vapor to air with less.
- Warm air can hold more water vapor than cool air. If air cools to the dew point, its water vapor may condense into liquid water.
- Hotter air rises and is lighter than cooler air (the stack effect).
States of matter
The three common states of matter are solid, liquid, and gas. Matter holds more heat energy as a gas than as a liquid, and more as a liquid than as a solid. A change from one state of matter to another takes much more energy than a temperature change within one state. This energy is latent heat. Energy usually must be removed to go from gas to liquid or from liquid to solid. Energy usually must be added to go from solid to liquid or from liquid to gas.
The cooling cycle
A heat pump cooling the house and an air-source air conditioner work in five steps.
- Through the large suction line, cool low-pressure refrigerant gas from the evaporator coil reaches the compressor. The compressor compresses it into superheated high-pressure gas.
- In the condenser coils, the fan helps move heat out of the superheated gas and into the outside air. When enough heat leaves it, the gas becomes a liquid. Less heat leaves when outside air is hotter, so efficiency falls as the outdoor temperature rises. Higher efficiency condensers usually carry more coil surface per ton of cooling capacity, because more coils remove more heat.
- The liquid flows under high pressure through the liquid line toward the evaporator coil. At the condenser unit, the liquid line should measure a few degrees warmer than outside air.
- At the evaporator coil, the high-pressure liquid enters a metering device (expansion device), which lowers its pressure and temperature. Some of the liquid flashes into gas. The liquid expands as it moves through the evaporator coil tubes and absorbs heat from the indoor air. That heat boils it into cool, low-pressure gas.
- The cool gas travels back to the compressor in the larger, insulated suction line, and the cycle starts again. One method of estimating the heat removed from the house is to compare suction line and liquid line temperatures at the compressor.
Metering device type depends on evaporator coil age.
- Unregulated orifice: found on older evaporator coils. It passes a fixed amount of refrigerant whatever the evaporator coil pressure. These devices are inefficient, and most coils with one have been replaced.
- Thermostatic expansion valve (TXV or TEV): found in most modern standard efficiency systems. An equalizer, a tube and sensor bulb filled with CO2, controls the flow. It senses evaporator coil pressure changes and opens or closes the valve.
- Electronic expansion valve (EEV): may be used in higher efficiency units. It gives better control over how fast refrigerant flows into the evaporator coil.
The heat pump heating cycle
- The reversing valve sits inside the condenser cabinet. Energizing it reverses refrigerant flow for heating mode.
- From the accumulator, the compressor receives cool low-pressure gas at its suction port and generates superheated high-pressure gas, which leaves at its discharge port.
- The superheated gas goes by way of the reversing valve and the larger, insulated line to the air handler's evaporator coil, now working as a condenser coil. There the air handler fan moves the gas's heat into the house, and the gas condenses to a liquid. At the air handler coil outlet, the gas should run a few degrees warmer than indoor air.
- The warm liquid moves under high pressure through the liquid tube toward the outdoor condenser.
- In the condenser, the liquid enters a metering device that lowers its pressure and temperature. It expands through the condenser coil, now working as an evaporator coil, and takes in heat from the outdoor air. That heat evaporates it into cool, low-pressure gas. Colder outside air gives up less heat, so efficiency drops as the outside temperature falls. Condensers with higher efficiency usually have more coil surface per ton of heating capacity. The point where the outside air holds too little heat is usually in the 30s F, depending on the system, and the backup heat strips should then turn on.
- The cool gas returns to the accumulator by way of the reversing valve, and the cycle starts again.
- Near or below 32 degrees F, frost may build up on the condenser fins. The heat pump should sense it and start a defrost cycle, putting the system in cooling mode for a few minutes. The frost is melted by heat removed from the house. While defrosting and afterward, water may be seen in and around the condenser, and cool air flows from the supply registers. Heat mode resumes when the defrost cycle is complete.
Determining air conditioning system capacity
A home inspector is not required to determine or confirm whether an air conditioner's Btu capacity is appropriate. A home inspector should still understand how capacity is determined, in order to interpret inspection results and to recognize significant oversizing or undersizing.
Ideally, the capacity should come within about 1/2 ton of the calculated capacity, if accurate data went into the calculation. An undersized system may fail to reach the desired temperature, especially in extreme conditions, which can lead to occupant comfort complaints. It may also run constantly, which can shorten its service life. An oversized system may activate and quickly deactivate. This is short-cycling. Reaching peak efficiency takes an air conditioner 10 to 20 minutes. Short-cycling therefore wastes energy and increases operating costs. A short-cycling system may also fail to dehumidify effectively. The resulting moisture problems can contribute to fungal growth and affect occupant comfort.
Load calculation
The cooling and heating loads of a house should be determined with the protocol in ACCA (Air Conditioning Contractors of America) Manual J. Manual S, also from ACCA, then uses those loads to select the recommended capacity. The calculations should be performed at construction and, in theory, at each new system installation. They are now done with computer software.
Manual J estimates the latent and the sensible load. Its inputs are:
- Latent load: location (design temperature and humidity), number of occupants based on bedrooms, occupant activities (breathing, cooking, bathing), and air infiltration rate, assumed or estimated from mechanical ventilation.
- Sensible load: orientation (north, south, east, west), geographic location, amount of insulation, air infiltration rate, and window type and size.
Rules of thumb
Some HVAC contractors, and home inspectors, estimate capacity with general rules. Their results are often significantly inaccurate, since the characteristics of each house are hard to adjust for. In many cases they lead to equipment of larger than required capacity. A home inspector should be wary of reporting a system as improperly sized on a rule of thumb alone.
Rule of thumb figures vary by region; one that fits Phoenix, AZ does not fit Chicago, IL.
Numbers and Rules to Memorize
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| No cooling system | Not a deficiency; consider reporting it |
| Permanently installed systems, through-wall units | In scope |
| Window units | Personal property, out of scope; report one not inspected |
| Special filters, air purifiers | Out of scope |
| 1 ton of refrigeration | 12,000 Btu per hour; 3 tons is 36,000 Btu |
| 1 Btu | Warms 1 pound of water 1 degree F |
| SEER | Minimum 14 in most of the U.S.; about 20 highest; older systems 10 or less |
| HSPF | About 7 to 10 |
| Refrigerant | R-22 (Freon) phased out; R-410A current |
| Suction line | Larger, insulated |
| Liquid line | Smaller, usually uninsulated |
| Liquid line at the condenser, cooling mode | A few degrees warmer than outside air |
| Heating mode, gas at the air handler coil outlet | A few degrees warmer than inside air |
| Ground-source heat pump | Closed-loop |
| Water-source heat pump | Open-loop or closed-loop |
| Ground-source and water-source efficiency | Up to 50 percent more than air-source; 5 to 10 years to recover the cost |
| Ground-source and water-source inspection | Operate, report obvious visible defects, recommend an HVAC contractor; otherwise out of scope |
| Radiant cooling, absorption coolers | Disclaim |
| Dual fuel system | Home inspector should be able to inspect it |
| Supplemental electric heat strips | Required where temperatures regularly fall below 30 degrees F |
| Backup heat strips activate | Usually in the 30s F, depending on the system |
| Frost on condenser fins | Near or below 32 degrees F; defrost runs cooling mode for a few minutes |
| Metering devices | Unregulated orifice (older), TXV (most standard efficiency), EEV (higher efficiency) |
| Capacity | Ideally within about 1/2 ton of the calculated capacity; home inspector not required to determine or confirm |
| Peak efficiency | 10 to 20 minutes of run time |
| Manual J, Manual S | Manual J for loads; Manual S for system capacity |
| Rules of thumb | Often significantly inaccurate and often too large; figures vary by region |